Hi Taylor!
Welcome to planDisney! Helping Guests from all over the world plan their perfect vacations to
Walt Disney World is one of my favourite things to do, so I am so happy you stopped by. I love planning which Disney Resort my family will call home during our vacation, and wow, have you picked some great ones to choose from. I am going to come out and say this upfront, I am biased, as
Disney's Wilderness Lodge is not only my favourite Disney Hotel at Disney World, it's one of my favourite places on Earth!
In terms of comfort, all the
Disney Resorts Collection hotels will offer comfortable sleeping arrangements, but a perk to staying at
Disney's Polynesian Village Resort is that it has some of the largest standard rooms at Disney World, which is great for families to have a little more room, especially for the little ones to play! All the resorts you've listed feature super fun pools with slides, and poolside activities are usually featured on the daily recreation schedule. The Polynesian has a brilliant splash pad-style area which my two boys absolutely loved! Each of the resorts listed also has some really great dining locations, too!
With a 5-year-old, you're likely going to want to consider taking a pushchair even if you don't use one at home, so being able to walk to a theme park can be really convenient. This will be an option at
Bay Lake Tower at Disney's Contemporary Resort, taking the walking path to Magic Kingdom, and
Disney's BoardWalk Villas will offer you a short walk to EPCOT. You can also walk from the Polynesian to Magic Kingdom, but this is a little longer, and can feel A LOT longer in the peak heat of the day.
Whilst you truly cannot go wrong when choosing where to stay at a Disney Resorts Collection hotel, the reason my family chooses Wilderness Lodge time and time again is the feeling of being a little out of the way in a calm national park-type setting, whilst also being so close to all of the fun of Magic Kingdom. We love taking the boat directly from the resort over to Magic Kingdom. There are also two great pools, and some brilliant dining options, including Whispering Canyon Cafe, which is a really fun place to enjoy a family meal. In the afternoon and evening, there is also boat transportation to
Disney's Fort Wilderness Resort and The Contemporary, so you can enjoy restaurants and shopping over there, too.
I hope this helps, Taylor! Have fun planning your first Walt Disney World vacation! If you have any other vacation planning questions, please
reach out to us here at planDisney!
See ya real soon!
Matt